Wednesday, January 9, 2013

National Taxpayer Advocate Delivers Annual Report to Congress; Focuses on Tax Reform, IRS Funding and Identity Theft



WASHINGTON — National Taxpayer Advocate Nina E. Olson today released her 2012 annual report to Congress, identifying the need for tax reform as the overriding priority in tax administration. The Advocate also expressed concern that the Internal Revenue Service is not adequately funded to serve taxpayers and collect tax, and identified ways in which this chronic underfunding harms taxpayers and the public fisc. She also found that the IRS is not doing enough to assist victims of tax-related identity theft and return preparer fraud.

TAX REFORM

The National Taxpayer Advocate’s annual report designates the complexity of the tax code as the #1 most serious problem facing taxpayers and recommends that Congress take significant steps to simplify it. “The existing tax code makes compliance difficult, requiring taxpayers to devote excessive time to preparing and filing their returns,” Olson wrote. “It obscures comprehension, leaving many taxpayers unaware how their taxes are computed and what rate of tax they pay; it facilitates tax avoidance by enabling sophisticated taxpayers to reduce their tax liabilities and provides criminals with opportunities to commit tax fraud; and it undermines trust in the system by creating an impression that many taxpayers are not compliant, thereby reducing the incentives that honest taxpayers feel to comply.”

Compliance Burdens. The report states that the tax code imposes a “significant, even unconscionable, burden on taxpayers.” Since 2001, Congress has made nearly 5,000 changes to the tax code, an average of more than one a day, and the number of words in the code appears to have reached nearly four million.
 
An analysis of IRS data by the Taxpayer Advocate Service (TAS) shows that individuals and businesses spend about 6.1 billion hours a year complying with tax-filing requirements. “If tax compliance were an industry, it would be one of the largest in the United States,” the report says. “To consume 6.1 billion hours, the ‘tax industry’ requires the equivalent of more than three million full-time workers.”
 
Individual taxpayers find return preparation so overwhelming that few do it on their own. Nearly 60 percent of taxpayers hire paid preparers, and another 30 percent rely on commercial software, with leading software packages costing $50 or more. In other words, taxpayers must spend money just to figure out how much money they owe.

Magnitude of “Tax Expenditures.” To reduce taxpayer burden and enhance public confidence in the integrity of the tax system, the report urges Congress to greatly simplify the tax code. In general, this means Congress should reassess the need for existing income exclusions, exemptions, deductions and credits (generally known as “tax expenditures”). For fiscal year (FY) 2013, the Joint Committee on Taxation has projected that tax expenditures will come to about $1.09 trillion, while individual income tax revenue is projected to be about $1.36 trillion. To put these numbers in perspective, if Congress were to eliminate all tax expenditures, straight math indicates it could cut individual income tax rates by 44 percent and still generate the same amount of revenue it collects under current rules.

Tax Policy Decisions and Revenue Decisions Should Be Made Separately and Then Married Up. The report recommends that Congress approach tax reform in a manner similar to zero-based budgeting. The starting assumption would be that all tax expenditures would be eliminated. A tax break would be retained only if a compelling case can be made that the benefits of that break outweigh the complexity burden it creates. “In performing this analysis,” Olson said in releasing the report, “we should look at each provision in the code and ask questions like: ‘Does this government incentive make sense?’; ‘If it does, is it better administered through the tax code or as a direct spending program?’; ‘However well intentioned, is it doing what it was intended to do?’; and ‘If yes, can it be administered without imposing unreasonable burdens on taxpayers or the IRS?’. At the same time, Congress can separately consider how much revenue it wants to raise, and it can then marry up our optimally designed tax system with our revenue needs by setting tax rates accordingly.”

Recommendations. The report recommends that Members of Congress take several steps, including:

1) Lay the groundwork for tax reform by holding meetings with constituents to discuss the complexity of the existing tax code and the trade-offs between tax rates and tax breaks that tax reform will require.

2) Apply a “zero-based budgeting” approach to comprehensive tax reform that starts out with the assumption that all tax benefits will be eliminated and then adds a benefit back only if Members conclude that, on balance, the public policy benefits of providing that benefit through the tax code outweigh the complexity it imposes on taxpayers.

IRS FUNDING
 
The IRS budget has been reduced in each of the last two fiscal years, and appears likely to face further cuts in coming years. Although these cuts reflect across-the-board reductions in federal discretionary spending, underfunding the IRS makes no sense, Olson said. “The IRS is materially different from other discretionary programs in that it serves as the de facto Accounts Receivable Department of the federal government. Each dollar appropriated for the IRS generates substantially more than one dollar in additional revenue. It is therefore ironic and counterproductive that concerns about the deficit are leading to cuts in the IRS budget, when those cuts are making the deficit larger.”
Olson added: “The plain truth is that the IRS’s mission trumps all other agencies’ missions, because without an effective revenue collector, you can’t fund those other agencies.”

IRS Funding Decisions Fail to Take Into Account “Return on Investment.” On a budget of $11.8 billion, the IRS collected $2.52 trillion in FY 2012. That translates to an average return-on-investment (ROI) of about 214:1. Yet the appropriations process treats the IRS like any other discretionary spending program, with no explicit recognition that each dollar appropriated for the IRS generates substantially more than one dollar in additional revenue. Last year, the IRS Commissioner estimated in a letter to Congress that proposed reductions in the IRS budget would cause tax collections to fall seven times as much.
 
“No business would fail to fund a unit that, on average, brought in $7 for every dollar spent. Shareholders would rebel and bring lawsuits, or at least oust the management or board of directors,” Olson wrote in her preface to the report. “Yet this is precisely what we are doing with the IRS budget.”

Lack of Funding Hampers Taxpayer Service. The report says that lack of funding is also preventing the IRS from meeting taxpayer needs. Since FY 2004, when taxpayer service levels peaked, the IRS’s performance in handling telephone calls and correspondence has been declining. In FY 2004, the IRS answered 87 percent of all calls seeking to reach a live telephone assister, and the average wait time was just over 2½ minutes. In FY 2012, the IRS answered just 68 percent of its calls, and those who got through spent an average of nearly 17 minutes waiting on hold. In FY 2012, the IRS received over 10 million letters in response to proposed tax adjustments, and at the end of the year, 48 percent of all taxpayer correspondence in its inventory had not been processed within established timeframes – up dramatically from 12 percent in FY 2004.
 
“Congress has enacted laws that now require more than 140 million individuals to file income tax returns,” Olson said. “When taxpayers are attempting to comply with laws that require them to turn over a significant portion of their incomes to pay our nation’s bills, they have a right to expect that their government will do a better job of taking their telephone calls and answering their letters.”

Lack of Funding Impairs Taxpayer Rights and Increases Taxpayer Burden. The report identifies numerous areas where lack of funding is causing taxpayer problems. “Nowhere is this more apparent than in the IRS’s increasing use of automated enforcement procedures,” Olson said. “To conserve resources, the IRS has largely automated its correspondence audits and its issuance of liens and levies. It typically moves forward with tax assessments without first talking to taxpayers to give them a chance to substantiate their return positions, and it proceeds with liens and levies before having a conversation to find out whether a tax delinquency is due to financial hardship, which would suggest that an installment agreement or offer-in-compromise should be considered.” The report notes that the IRS’s limited resources to conduct outreach and education to taxpayers (particularly small businesses) and to enforce the laws also contribute to its inability to close the annual tax gap, which was most recently estimated at nearly $400 billion in 2006. The report points out that noncompliance violates the rights of compliant taxpayers, who indirectly pay more tax to make up the shortfall. Based on Census Bureau data, the average household effectively paid an extra $3,300 in tax in 2006 to subsidize noncompliance by others. 

Recommendations. The report recommends that Congress:

1) Consider revising the budget rules so that the IRS is “fenced off” from otherwise applicable spending ceilings and is funded at a level designed to maximize tax compliance, particularly voluntary compliance, with due regard for protecting taxpayer rights and minimizing taxpayer burden.

2) Keep in mind in allocating IRS resources that tax compliance requires an appropriate balance between high quality taxpayer service and effective tax-law enforcement, and funding should be provided in a manner that allows the IRS to maintain such a balance.

TAX-RELATED IDENTITY THEFT
 
The number of tax-related identity theft incidents has increased substantially in recent years. Within TAS, identity theft case receipts increased by more than 650 percent from FY 2008 to FY 2012. At the end of FY 2012, the IRS had almost 650,000 identity-theft cases in its inventory servicewide. The problem has grown worse as organized criminal actors have found ways to steal the Social Security numbers (SSNs) of taxpayers, file tax returns using those taxpayers’ names and SSNs, and obtain fraudulent tax refunds. Then, when the real taxpayer files a return claiming the refund, that return is rejected. The impact on victims is significant. More than 75 percent of taxpayers filing returns are due refunds, which average some $3,000 and are not paid until the IRS fully resolves a case.

IRS Commitments. In 2008, the IRS Commissioner testified about identity theft before a Senate Finance Committee hearing. He stated: “My overall goal as the IRS Commissioner is that when a taxpayer [who is an identity theft victim] contacts us with an issue or concern, we have in place a seamless process that gets the issue resolved promptly.” Later that year, the IRS established an “Identity Protection Specialized Unit” (or “IPSU”), which was designed to provide centralized assistance to victims of identity theft. The National Taxpayer Advocate supported the commitment to centralized and prompt victim assistance.
IRS Performance. The report says the IRS has created numerous task forces and other teams in recent years in an attempt to improve its identity theft processes, yet victims still face the same “labyrinth of procedures and drawn-out timeframes for resolution” that they faced five years ago. The IRS is instructing its employees to advise identity theft victims that it will take 180 days – half a year – to resolve their cases. Complicated cases inevitably will take longer. Thus, the IRS’s procedural changes are not providing faster relief.
 
The report also says the IRS has decided to reverse course and decentralize victim assistance. It recently created specialized units within each of 21 individual functions to work on identity theft cases, apparently under the belief that most identity theft cases involve a single issue that the relevant specialized unit can work most efficiently. The report expresses concern about this backtracking from a centralized approach.

One-Stop Shopping Needed. TAS itself handled nearly 55,000 identity theft cases in FY 2012, most of which involved multiple issues that required actions by multiple units. The report expresses concern that creation of 21 specialized units will erode the centralized role of the IPSU, require taxpayers to speak with multiple functions, increase the time it takes to resolve cases, and heighten the risk that some issues may not be addressed.
 
“Taxpayers need ‘one-stop shopping’ – a single point of contact they can work with to resolve all issues in their cases – and the IRS needs a ‘traffic cop’ to make sure that all units complete their actions and that parts of cases do not fall through the cracks,” Olson said. “And six months is an unacceptable period of time to expect taxpayer-victims to wait. The IRS must do more to provide the prompt and seamless assistance to identity theft victims that Commissioner Shulman promised.”
 
OTHER KEY ISSUES ADDRESSED
 
Federal law requires the Advocate’s Annual Report to Congress to identify at least 20 of the “most serious problems” encountered by taxpayers and make administrative and legislative recommendations to mitigate those problems. Overall, this year’s report identifies 23 problems, provides updates on six previously identified problems, makes dozens of recommendations for administrative change, makes seven recommendations for legislative change, and analyzes the 10 tax issues most frequently litigated in the federal courts.
 
Among the “most serious problems" addressed are the following:
  • The IRS’s failure to provide tax refunds to victims of preparer fraud. When a taxpayer is victimized by a preparer who receives a fraudulent refund by paper check, the IRS will issue a replacement refund to the taxpayer. However, the IRS will not issue a replacement refund when a taxpayer is victimized by a preparer who receives the fraudulent refund by altering the bank routing number on a direct-deposit request, even though the IRS has received legal advice that it may do so. Olson says the taxpayer-victim is legally entitled to receive the refund, and the IRS has no legal basis for withholding it.
  • The IRS’s extraordinarily high audit rate of taxpayers who claim the adoption tax credit. Congress created the adoption tax credit to help low and middle income families afford the costs of an adoption, which are estimated to run as high as $40,000. Yet the IRS, partly using income-based rules, selected 69 percent of tax returns claiming the credit during the 2012 filing season for audit, compared with one percent of returns overall. These audits imposed significant burden on the affected taxpayers for several reasons, most notably because the median refund claim constituted nearly one-quarter of the taxpayers’ adjusted gross income for the year, and the audits on average took over four months. Despite the burden, the payoff was relatively small. The IRS denied only about 10 percent of the amounts claimed in tax year 2010, and as of mid-November had denied only about 1.5 percent of the amounts claimed in tax year 2011. The excessive focus on returns claiming the adoption credit burdened many taxpayers and could have the effect of negating Congress’s intent to encourage adoptions, the report says.
  • The IRS’s Offshore Voluntary Disclosure programs and their failure to distinguish adequately between “bad actors” and “benign actors.” The IRS has sought to increase enforcement of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) reporting requirements in recent years and has offered a series of voluntary disclosure programs designed to settle with taxpayers who had failed to file required FBAR forms. However, the report says, the programs generally applied a “one-size-fits-all” approach that required the payment of significant penalties and did not distinguish between “bad actors” and “benign actors.” By generally requiring taxpayers who make voluntary disclosures to “opt out” of the disclosure program and submit to comprehensive audits in order to avoid draconian penalties, the report argues that the program has caused excessive burden and fear for taxpayers who had reasonable cause for not filing FBAR forms or whose failure to file was inadvertent.
Research Study on Factors Influencing Voluntary Tax Compliance by Small Businesses.

Volume 2 of the report contains six research studies, including preliminary results of a survey of sole proprietors that TAS commissioned to better understand factors that may affect income tax reporting compliance. The Advocate’s office undertook the study because the IRS has estimated that only 43 percent of sole proprietor income is reported on tax returns, representing the largest portion of the tax gap (i.e., tax that is owed but is not timely and voluntarily paid). Developing a more complete picture of the attitudes of this category of taxpayers therefore could assist the IRS in improving tax compliance. Based on IRS computer scoring of the likely compliance level of tax returns, the Advocate’s office selected a sample of the most compliant and the least compliant returns and commissioned an anonymous survey of certain groups of these taxpayers to determine attitudinal and other differences. Among the preliminary findings:
  • Respondents in the high-compliance group expressed more trust in government and the IRS.
  • Respondents from low-compliance communities were suspicious of the tax system and its fairness.
  • Respondents in the high-compliance group were more likely to use return preparers.
  • Taxpayers in the low-compliance groups expressed less trust in tax preparers and were less likely to use them or follow their advice.
  • Low-compliance taxpayers tended to be clustered in certain communities.
 * * * * *
Please visit www.taxpayeradvocate.irs.gov/2012AnnualReport for more information about this report, including an Executive Summary, downloadable infographics on the Most Serious Problems, and videos of the National Taxpayer Advocate discussing key issues.

Tuesday, January 8, 2013

IRS Provides Updated Withholding Guidance for 2013



The Internal Revenue Service released updated income-tax withholding tables for 2013 reflecting this week’s changes by Congress.

IRS Plans Jan. 30 Tax Season Opening For 1040 Filers

WASHINGTON — Following the January tax law changes made by Congress under the American Taxpayer Relief Act (ATRA), the Internal Revenue Service announced today it plans to open the 2013 filing season and begin processing individual income tax returns on Jan. 30.

The IRS will begin accepting tax returns on that date after updating forms and completing programming and testing of its processing systems. This will reflect the bulk of the late tax law changes enacted Jan. 2. The announcement means that the vast majority of tax filers -- more than 120 million households -- should be able to start filing tax returns starting Jan 30.

The IRS estimates that remaining households will be able to start filing in late February or into March because of the need for more extensive form and processing systems changes. This group includes people claiming residential energy credits, depreciation of property or general business credits. Most of those in this group file more complex tax returns and typically file closer to the April 15 deadline or obtain an extension.

“We have worked hard to open tax season as soon as possible,” IRS Acting Commissioner Steven T. Miller said. “This date ensures we have the time we need to update and test our processing systems.”

The IRS will not process paper tax returns before the anticipated Jan. 30 opening date. There is no advantage to filing on paper before the opening date, and taxpayers will receive their tax refunds much faster by using e-file with direct deposit.

“The best option for taxpayers is to file electronically,” Miller said.

The opening of the filing season follows passage by Congress of an extensive set of tax changes in ATRA on Jan. 1, 2013, with many affecting tax returns for 2012. ‬While the IRS worked to anticipate the late tax law changes as much as possible, the final law required that the IRS update forms and instructions as well as make critical processing system adjustments before it can begin accepting tax returns.

The IRS originally planned to open electronic filing this year on Jan. 22; more than 80 percent of taxpayers filed electronically last year.

Who Can File Starting Jan. 30?

The IRS anticipates that the vast majority of all taxpayers can file starting Jan. 30, regardless of whether they file electronically or on paper. The IRS will be able to accept tax returns affected by the late Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) patch as well as the three major “extender” provisions for people claiming the state and local sales tax deduction, higher education tuition and fees deduction and educator expenses deduction.

Who Can’t File Until Later?

There are several forms affected by the late legislation that require more extensive programming and testing of IRS systems. The IRS hopes to begin accepting tax returns including these tax forms between late February and into March; a specific date will be announced in the near future.

The key forms that require more extensive programming changes include Form 5695 (Residential Energy Credits), Form 4562 (Depreciation and Amortization) and Form 3800 (General Business Credit). A full listing of the forms that won’t be accepted until later is available on IRS.gov.

As part of this effort, the IRS will be working closely with the tax software industry and tax professional community to minimize delays and ensure as smooth a tax season as possible under the circumstances.

Updated information will be posted on IRS.gov.

Wednesday, November 21, 2012

Tax Points - Legal Fees

Marital actions. As a general rule, attorney’s fees in marital and custody actions are not deductible. This is so even if marital assets include a business or investment property. If legal fees are for tax advice, they are deductible. Also, legal fees paid to protect a certain asset may be added to basis. It is important for the attorney to separately bill for such services. Child support and property settlements incident to a divorce are non-taxable, so related attorney’s fees are nondeductible. Loophole: In the case of a spouse who pays attorney’s fees to secure alimony, the fees are deductible, since the alimony is taxable.

Social security claims. Attorney’s fees to establish a claim to Social Security benefits, (e.g., to qualify for disability payments) are deductible to the extent that the benefits are taxable. Depending on income, up to 85% of benefits may be taxable – so that portion of the fees may be deductible as a miscellaneous itemized deduction.

Criminal actions. Generally, attorney’s fees to defend oneself in a criminal matter are not deductible. For example, fees to mount a Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act defense are not deductible even if an adverse determination results in forfeiture of property under the law. However, if the case arises in a business context, the fees may be deductible.

How To Compare After-Tax Bond Yields

When you are deciding whether to buy tax-exempt municipal bonds or taxable corporate bonds, your tax bracket will tell you whether the lower interest on tax-free bonds makes them a better investment. Here’s a simple way to help you make the right decision.

1. Divide the tax-free yield by the taxable yield.

2. Subtract the result from 100%. This will give you the tax bracket at which each of the investments will result in the same yield.

3. If you are in a higher tax bracket than the bracket you calculated in step two, the tax-free bond will give you a higher after-tax yield. If you are in a lower tax-bracket, the taxable bond will give you a better after-tax yield.

For example, assume that you are considering a tax-free bond that yields 6% and a taxable bond that yields 8%.

1. 6% divided by 8% equals 75%.

2. 100% less 75% equals 25%.

3. If your tax bracket is higher than 25%, the tax-free bond will give you a greater return. If your tax bracket is less than 25%, the taxable bond will give you a better return.

Tax Points

Succession planning loophole. Sell your business on an installment plan. This freezes the value at the current price. The seller reports capital gain on the installment basis, delaying taxes because gain is recognized only when and to the extent that installment payments are received. Interest must be added to the payments. The purchaser’s note will be included in the seller’s estate and the unpaid balance (the remaining portion of the capital gain), even though not yet received will be subject to income tax upon death.

Bonus depreciation. Under the law, businesses are entitled to claim 50% bonus depreciation for eligible new property placed in service in 2012. This means that half the cost of the property can be deducted in the first year, along with any additional depreciation on the other half of the property’s cost, as well as any first-year expensing.

Business use of personal cars. If you drive your personal car, truck or van for business, you can deduct the operating expenses related to business use. There are two ways to do this…Actual expense method. You can deduct your actual expenses related to business use of the vehicle – gasoline, oil, tires, repairs, insurance, etc. – plus an allowance for depreciation. Standard mileage rate. Deduct business driving in 2012 at the IRS rate of 55.5¢ per mile. This cents-per-mile allowance takes the place of actual expenses.

Tax Tips

Credit card settlements
People with large credit card debt sometimes are able to settle for less than the full amount owed. If someone owes $25,000 and settles the debt in full for, say $8,000, the $17,000 difference is taxable income.

Loophole: This income is not recognized for tax purposes if the debt relief is part of a personal bankruptcy settlement or if the debtor is insolvent immediately before the debt cancellation.

Even in those situations, the lender will send a Form 1099-C, Cancellation of Debt, to the IRS reporting the cancellation of debt as income. To avoid tax, you must complete and attach Form 982, Reduction of Tax Attributes Due to Discharge of Indebtedness, to your tax return.

Long-term-disability insurance payments
Some employees who become disabled receive payment under an employer-provided disability policy.

These policies are often included in compensation packages as a tax-free fringe benefit. Other companies have cafeteria plans offering an array of benefits, including disability insurance, that employees must choose from. The tax treatment of these benefits depends entirely on who paid the premiums…

If the employer paid, benefits are taxable.

If the employee paid, benefits are tax free.

Tax Tip - Inherited Property

If you sell inherited property at a loss, you can deduct the loss on your tax return.

Example: Your parents leave you a house with an original purchase price of $100,000, and a market value of $300,000. You inherit the house estate tax free, receive a “stepped-up” basis of $300,000, and hold it as an investment (you do not live in it). When you sell the house for, say, $260,000, you
can deduct $40,000, subject to annual loss deduction limits. (As mentioned earlier capital losses are deductible dollar for dollar against capital gains and can offset up to $3,000 of ordinary income each year. Excess losses are carried forward to subsequent tax years.)

Added benefit: The loss is deductible even if it is created by brokerage commission payments.

2012 Year End Tax Savers

College savings. Some states allow state income tax deductions for contributions to Section 529 college savings plans. If your state does, and you’re planning to send a child to college, consider making one.

Individual retirement accounts. Convert a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA to obtain future tax-free investment returns from the Roth IRA while escaping minimum annual distribution requirements. Added benefit: You can reconsider and reverse the conversion if you later decide it is not in your best interest or that you can make the conversion at a lower tax cost later if the value of your account had dropped – as late as October 15, 2013. You may reverse a conversion only once in a single year.

Capital losses. Take capital losses to end up with a $3,000 net loss for the year. A loss of up to that amount is deductible against ordinary income.

Combined Payrolls Can Produce Tax Savings

It’s not unusual for closely-held corporations to operate through more than one division and for key employees to be on the payroll of both. If an employee’s combined salary from each corporation totals more than $110,100 excess Social Security taxes might be incurred.

There’s a way, however, to avoid this problem. Instead of each corporation issuing its own payroll check, designate one company in the group as a common paymaster, which can issue one check to the employee on behalf of all the companies involved. To do this, you must meet one of these three criteria:

• The corporations involved must have at least 50% common ownership.
• Half or more of the officers of one corporation must also be officers of another.
• The corporations must share at least 30% of their employees.

The result? Let’s say an employee is drawing a $100,000 annual salary from each of two corporations. Since the maximum Social Security tax is owed on the first $110,100 paid by each employer, the company will have to pay taxes on $200,000 in total. If a single check from the common paymaster company is issued, $89,900 of the total amount will be exempt from excess Social Security taxes.